By Sherry Lipp

WARNING – SPOILERS AHEAD

I’m just going to start right off and say I have extreme mixed feelings about this week’s episode of Once Upon a Time, titled “The Doctor.” I have long since wondered what role the mysterious Dr. Whale (David Anders) played in the overall storyline. Now that I know, I’m disappointed. I feel this episode has broken all its own rules by introducing a storyline and character that doesn’t belong in this show at all. It further increases the confusion of an already unfocused season.

We never before have seen any back story for Dr. Whale. He never appeared in any of the flashbacks, and has always seemed like kind of an outsider. That was for good reason. Dr. Whale is not a part of the world of fairytales at all. It’s not revealed until the end of the episode (and if you haven’t seen the episode, please stop reading if you don’t want to know who he is) but Dr. Whale is actually Dr. Victor Frankenstein. It seems Once Upon a Time is alluding that all works of fiction have their own realm, and apparently all are fair game for the show.

There are many problems inherent in this. The most glaring is that the world of Frankenstein does not really fit with the world of enchantment. Mary Shelley’s cautionary tale has pretty much nothing to do with the world of magic. Unlike novels such as Frankenstein, fairy tales are stories that permeate across many cultures and have often been handed down from generation to generation. They’re generally not the unique creation of a single author. The stories have of course been adapted and boiled down to the versions we are familiar with today – the Disney versions. Granted, not every single character and story in the show is from a fairy tale like this, most notably Alice in Wonderland.

To be honest, I felt a little squirmy when they first introduced Wonderland into the equation. I didn’t feel quite like that belonged, but it fit well enough tonally that I didn’t spend a lot of time thinking about it. Also they have stuck with just The Mad Hatter/Jefferson (Sebastian Stan), who got to Wonderland from the fairytale world in the first place (at least in the world of this show, he did). In the case of Dr. Whale, he came to the fairytale world from his Frankenstein realm (for lack of any better term for it), purposefully to get a heart so he can bring his dead brother back to life. So here is my problem. The character of Dr. Frankenstein is fully established by Mary Shelley in her novel. It feels like they are stealing it (not literally, because the story is apparently in the public domain) to do with it what they want. I find it disrespectful to the original novel.

The Mad Hatter is at least a side character. Like everyone else in Once Upon a Time, they are extrapolating on characters beyond the lives we know from the stories. Sending Dr. Frankenstein to the Enchanted Forest changes everything established about him in the novel. Then there is the little joke with his name. It’s an inside joke that doesn’t quite work. The 1931 film Frankenstein was directed by the very real James Whale. So why would Dr. Whale have the name of a real person who directed a loose adaptation of Shelley’s classic novel? I guess maybe he was aware the curse as well. I don’t know. Were they really planning this the whole time, or did Whale originally refer to something else?

The sad thing is, I liked where the resurrection storyline led. I just wish they had come up with a different way to do it. It all tied back in with Regina’s (Lana Parrilla) transformation into the Evil Queen. The best parts of the episode were when Rumplestiltskin (Robert Carlyle) was trying to teach Regina the ways of black magic. The part where she was unable to kill the unicorn actually made me sad for her (I was glad she couldn’t kill the unicorn). I could write another entire essay on how if she had gone back and killed the unicorn (instead of a person) when she embraced her power, it would have made me not like her at all.

In the meantime, Emma (Jennifer Morrison), Snow (Ginnifer Goodwin), Aurora (Sarah Bolger), and Mulan (Jamie Chung) were running around with Captain Hook (Colin O’Donoghue). It wasn’t all that interesting until Hook struck a bargain with them and revealed that he wants revenge against Rumplestiltskin.

I know this was a rather harsh assessment of the Dr.Whale/Frankenstein situation, but I had a very strong reaction to it. Nonetheless, now that it’s there it’s not going to go away, and it did leave me with some questions. How was Dr. Whale trapped in the curse? Does this imply all stories ever written are subject to the curse, or did he travel back to Fairytale Land just in time to be trapped in it?

I seriously hope this show develops a story I can get behind. Why have they been teasing things they never seem to get back to? Personally I think they should focus more on Rumplestiltskin’s quest to find his son, and Regina’s conflict about whether she can truly develop a relationship with Henry (Jared Gilmore) or not. Only time will tell if the unraveling of Once Upon a Time will continue.

Photos: ABC

http://feeds.feedburner.com/CinemaLowdown
Sherry Lipp
Sherry is a writer/blogger specializing in entertainment and food writing. You can find her gluten and grain-free food articles at scdforlife.com.

8 thoughts on “TV Review: Once Upon a Time Season 2 Episode 5 “The Doctor”

  1. I think you got so caught up in Dr. Whale turning out to be Dr. Frankenstein, you failed to really comment on the episode.

  2. Hi Rosie – yes, I did have a strong reaction to that. It detracted from everything else for me. I did include some thoughta on the other elements in the last couple of paragraphs – I did like the Regina storyline. Unfortunately the Frankenstein storyline ended up overshadowing.

    Thanks!

  3. Last season, I was really caught up in the characters and what happening. This season, they just keep introducing these really one dimensional characters that I’m not sure even belong and couldn’t care less about. Mulan and Sleeping Beauty have done nothing that make me “know” them and I agree that the Dr. Whale identity completely overshadowed what I did like about this episode.

  4. Hi Gloria – thanks for the comment. I agree with you about Mulan and Sleeping Beauty.

    Yes, Dr. Whale was a big surprise. Though I wasn’t crazy about who he is, I am curious about where they are going with it.

  5. I really enjoyed this article & I like how you commented on the origin of Whale’s name. To me, I think the show seems to be indicating that Fairytale Land, Neverland & Wonderland (and possibly other lands) each exist as their own separate entities & parts of them were all struck by the Curse because people from them all knew Regina or visited Fairytale Land at one point. Regina could/can manipulate her magic to harm who she wants. A good tumblr to follow (if you’re interested, though it does have spoilers) is http://fyouat-ask.tumblr.com/

    This is a Q&A only blog that coincides with the f*ckyeahonceuponatime tumblr. It often liveblogs during the show each Sunday. I asked a question during one show, and another user & the blog’s moderator seemed to agree with me that when Regina pushed Cora “through the looking glass,” she fell into Wonderland. So the woman behind the white fan on the throne that Jefferson & Regina saw in Season 1 during their visit to Wonderland was Cora (meaning she is/was the Queen of Hearts). So even though these lands/myths exist separately, maybe they tie together somehow? Although the show is dragging along at the moment, you have to realize ABC will probably want to make at least 5 seasons.

    – Jordan
    http://www.reallifein3d.tumblr.com

  6. Thanks for the comment and the tip on the tumblr Jordan!

    I agree, I think they are creating separate realms that have somehow been connected. I think the Alice in Wonderland worked better than Frankenstein.

    So will there be a Star Wars realm now? (I hope not)

  7. No problem! And I agree; although I’m not an Alice in Wonderland fan by nature (I didn’t enjoy the books when I read them), I like Jefferson’s character on the show & I like that realm on the show better, too. I’m a Star Wars fan, but a Star Wars realm on OUAT would just be way too far! But Disney just bought Lucasfilm & Disney also owns ABC, so you never know lol!

    – Jordan
    http://www.reallifein3d.tumblr.com

Leave a Comment